Later on this evening in New York, Rob Bell is speaking to launch his new book, 'Love wins: A book about heaven, hell and the fate of every person who ever lived'.Obviously I have not read the book yet, but I have read reviews and blogs by people who have and quite a few by people who haven't. Being a bit of a Rob Bell fan, and having found two of his previous books challenging and rewarding I am looking forward to this new offering.
What seems of have got so many people hot under the collar is what Rob Bell actually says about hell. The main charge appears to be that in this book Rob Bell has become a universalist - teaching that everyone will go to heaven whatever they believe about Jesus - because fundamentally God is love.
As I say, I haven't read the book - so what am I blogging about it for?
What is of more concern to me at the moment is not so much what Bell says or not - but it is how those who call themselves Christians respond to those they don't agree with.
Jesus said things like, 'love one another...by this everyone will know that you are my disciples' (John 13:34-35), and 'love your enemies' (Matthew 5:44).
USA Today reports that the run up to this book's release has 'provoked weeks of fierce infighting among pastors, theologians and anyone else who scans the Christian blogosphere where critics rage that he's a hipster heretic'. Fierce infighting - strong language.
Rob Bell is no stranger to criticism, and I am sure that there are those among his critics who see this as the final nail in the Rob Bell coffin, hence the Tweet - 'Goodbye Rob Bell'. This is the final proof that Rob Bell is indeed a heretic and that any right minded Christian should have nothing to do with him.
In an address to his church yesterday morning Rob Bell said that his starting point for this book is the belief that God is love.
Whatever we might disagree about, God is love, and God calls us to be loving. If I have learnt anything over the last few years it's lessons about God's grace, about seeing the best in people, about giving people the benefit of the doubt. When I come to read this book (and it won't be right away) I may either agree or disagree with all or parts of Rob Bell's argument - but there is a sense in which that doesn't matter. Whatever his argument I am sure it will be a challenging and thought provoking read.
But Jesus didn't tell us that we will be known as his disciples because we've won the argument - but because of our love for each other. Even if I disagree with the whole book Rob Bell will always be welcome at my house for dinner - if he's ever in the neighbourhood!
2 comments:
I hope that you will do a review on this book as it will be interesting to see if he really does say all that stuff about hell.
I agree with you about the way that we should treat each other. For the media to be picking up on 'infighting' is not glorifying to God.
HOWEVER
From what I've heard of Rob Bell (and I haven't actually read any of his books so can't really have an opinion!) he seems to go out of the way to be controversial.
He is obviously an influential teacher but I’ve heard lots of people say he’s confusing and that he words things in a way that gets people’s backs up.
I liked this quote from the review you posted on Facebook:
“Christians do not need more confusion. They need clarity. They need teachers who are willing to deal honestly with what the Bible says, no matter how hard that truth is. And let’s be honest—many truths are very, very hard to swallow.”
Jesus tells us to love one another, but he wasn’t shy about rebuking false teachers etc.
Although maybe it’s not done in the right way at all, I can understand the frustration behind all the comments. YOU can read his books with a background of sound doctrine and understanding and pick out the dodgy bits, but what about non-Christians or people who are younger in their faith with less understanding?
Hmm…anyway. I look forward to your thoughts when you’ve read the book!
Thanks for your sober minded comment... I am reading the book at the moment and have immense moments of joy and revelation in it as well as moments of confusion and questioning.
I just read this comment on another blog, "Do you agree with Rob Bell's book or not?". This to me is a silly question. We should read it with an openness to his giftings and failings and let the Spirit speak to us. Why is everyone so scared?
Post a Comment